Outlook Web access (OWA) vs. Google Mail for teacher use – I’ve #goneGoogle
I’m issued with an email account with Outlook Web Access (OWA) for my school email address (hosted by EMBC). I don’t actually use it much – I prefer to use my Google Apps Gmail account as a client for my work address in preference to Outlook (which I just can’t make myself like) or the Outlook web interface.
I’d only recently noticed that the interface you get depends on the web browser you use. If like me you use Firefox as your primary browser at work, a huge chunk of functionality is missing already (gee thanks Microsoft!). The screen grabs below give an idea of the differences.
Straight away I’m using a clunky interface that looks like something from the Nineties to manage my email. Compare that to Google mail which looks the same in IE, Firefox or Chrome (and I have all 3 browsers installed on all my laptops!).
I was going to write a comparison of the two platforms but it’s hard to find an aspect that OWA excels at. Contact management is a joke, the PIM functions make me want to stab myself with a biro in frustration and anyone who has used Google mail knows the advantages of tagging mail versus folders.
Most teachers work as much from home as they do from work, if not more. I know I do. I like to have access to my emails from home and when I visit other schools. All of my email that is, not the last two or three in my inbox. I never take my laptop home – who’d want to use that piece of junk in preference to my own modern machine – which means I need access to email in the cloud. Look at the generous mail allocation I get from work versus Google Apps email – I can search through archived emails and contacts with ease using the Google interface, without having to fire up a desktop mail client to achieve the same result. It might help if EMBC gave you a reasonable amount of space – 100Mb is nothing, I’ve sent more email than that in a day!
(Compare that to the standard space allocation provided with Gmail and you see a world of difference.)
Fortunately Google Mail will retrieve emails from my work address, and send replies that look as though they have come from my work address, so I don’t have to soil my hands with Outlook Web Access (or a desktop client).
Until Microsoft comes up with a better interface that works well with Firefox, and EMBC can give us sufficient storage, I’ll continue to use the Google mail interface as my primary mail client. What’s your email client of choice and why?


